This review is from Model
Railroad News, VOL 4, Iss
6, June 1998. Reprinted with permission of
Lamplight Publishing Company.
Atlas
O & N Scale Interlocking Tower Kits
by
Jeff Saxton
Atlas
has entered the O scale market recently with a
new company, Atlas O. One of their first releases
is a nice sized Interlocking Tower kit. The model
is also newly available in N scale from parent
company, Atlas. Both are so similar, my friend
John lee and I decided to combine two reviews.
Each kit is nearly identical, except for size
itself. Atlas also manufactures this kit in HO
scale as well.
The
prototype for this structure is unknown to me,
but it is very reminiscent of several on the C
& O in Virginia and West Virginia. Im
sure there were other similar designs around the
country, and this model will fit into a wide
variety of layouts nicely.
The
kits are molded in pre-colored styrene; a
pleasing brick red, wood tan, dark brown, and
medium gray. The kits include pre-printed acetate
window glazing sheets, as well as pre-printed
signs. All parts were cleanly molded, and little
to no flash was evident.
Using
the well laid out instruction sheets, we were
each able to assemble the models in about
one-and-a-half hours. Assembly was
straight-forward, and only one hitch was met,
more on which later.
The N
scale kit comes with a molded base plate, which
aided in aligning the small wall sections, the O
scale kit required no such part. There is also an
amount of extra goodies molded in the kit, to let
you place them where you wish, for individuality.
On the O scale kit, there is even an amount of
interior fittings, to represent the interlocking
levers themselves, a very nice touch in so large
and visible an interior.
All
parts fit well, and required no modifications to
allow the kit to be assembled in the manner the
instructions called out, except the window
glazing. In both models, the window glazing is a
sheet of pre-printed acetate, with dashed
outlines showing where to cut the individual
windows from the carrier sheet. In both kits, the
dashed lines are too large, and it required some
careful cutting and tedious hand-work to get them
down to the proper size. in fact, John Lee merely
used Micro-Scale Krystal Klear when it became
more effort than it was worth!
The
instructions are a little unclear in this area as
well. The glaze should fit between the wall and
the inside of the window (place the glazing in
the wall opening first, then add the window
sash). With the glazing cut too large, this is
truly impossible, so you must trim to fit, all
the while keeping the printed images on the
glazing centered on the opening. this aspect was
our only complaint, the rest of the kit
assembling cleanly and neatly.
The O
scale kit measures, overall, 8" x 4" x
7" tall, and the N scale model is about
2.5" x 1.2" x 2" tall. the base of
both models is fairly narrow, so it should be no
problem to shoe-horn these into yard layouts
where they would usually be seen.
These
kits would be very good beginning points for a
variety of kit-bashing projects, and should not
be over looked from that viewpoint as well. Both
John Lee and myself feel these kits are a good
value for the money, and we recommend them to MRN
readers.
Tie
size and spacing, however, are where Atlas stands
alone. Prototype mainline track is generally laid
with ties on 22" or 23" centers, and
Atlas has used 22" centers for its ties.
Compared to GarGraves-type track, the Atlas
product has nearly half again as many ties for a
given length of track. The Atlas ties also have a
smaller, more prototypical cross section, and
each tie has molded-in tie plates (the metal
plates on which the rail rests) and spikes.
Wood
grain is molded into the tops but not the ends of
the Atlas ties. Being plastic, Atlas ties should
not fade in color with age, as model wood ties
often do. The Atlas rail has a goldish tint,
which Atlas tells us is characteristic of all
nickel silver rail.
The
center rail is chemically blackened to make it
less apparent. However, Atlas tells us the
blackening does wear off with use. Abrasive track
cleaners (like Bright Boy) will remove the
blackening almost immediately.
A
rugged feel is also characteristic of Atlas O
track. Picking up a piece, youre
immediately struck by how heavy and solid it
feels. Since 3-railers seems to design layouts
that have to be walked on occasionally to
retrieve a derailed train, we jumped on the Atlas
track several times (in our sneakers) to see how
it hold up. No problem- this track can take it.
Assembly
Atlas
O track uses the same type of slide-on rail
joiners used on sectional HO track; the only
difference is that the O gauge joiners are
detailed with bolt heads to look like the
fishplates that connect prototype rail. The rail
joiners carry current from one section to another
and help keep the rails aligned. In addition, a
snap-lock connector built into the plastic tie
base holds track sections together, forming a
tight and positive joint. We connected two sample
pieces together 30 times and found no tendency
for the joint to loosed with use.
The
metal rail joiners on our samples, however, did
have a tendency to loosen very easily, sometimes
failing to carry current to the next section.
Checking with Atlas O, we found that our track
was very early production and that the rail
joiners have since been redesigned for a tighter,
more reliable fit.
Fit
between track sections is also very good, with
virtually no gap between the rails.
Current
is supplied to the rails through terminal rail
joiners simply a pair of rail joiners with
wires soldered to them. Curiously, a set of these
includes only two joiners, so power is supplied
to only one outer rail (the two outer rails are
internally not connected to each other). If
youve got a soldering gun, these terminal
joiners would be a cinch to make yourself. Atlas
also makes a nifty plastic rail joiner with a
tiny vertical insulating tab for situations when
you need to electrically isolate one rail from
another.
Its
important to mention that this is a product
designed for permanent layout builders and is
perhaps not the best track for under-the-tree
use, temporary layouts on the living room carpet
or frequent setup and disassembly by children.
The Atlas track has superb looks and a fine
system for locking the sections together, but it
will work best when screwed down to the layout
surface.
Geometry
Putting
Atlas O track together for the first time, I was
struck by how smooth the transition is from an
O54 curve to a straight section; the rails just
seem to flow from one section to another. This is
something one does not get with O31 curves, where
trains seems to snap into and out of the curves
(what my wife refers to as s.o.b. turns: slide
over, baby!).
It is
telling that the first Atlas O curves are in O54,
and the next size to arrive will be O72. This is
clearly a product aimed at operators longing for
realism and smooth operation. Jim Weaver of Atlas
O stresses that "we are fully committed to
introducing a full line of track a true
system enabling 3-railers to construct virtually
any layout without having to cut and fit track
sections. Most of the design work is already
completed, and we will be introducing new pieces
on a steady basis."
Soon
to come are straight fitter pieces in 1.75",
4.5" and 5.5" lengths; a
40"straight is also in the works, as well as
a layout design book. Because O31 and O42 curves
dont match the Atlas geometry, an O36 curve
(same radius as Lionel Super-O) with matching
switches will be introduced, hopefully by the end
of the year.
As we
were going to press the first O54 switches had
not yet arrived, but we will report on them in a
future issue.
Compatibility
For
operators with an investment in another track
system, Atlas is trying to make it easy to use
21st Century Track to expand an existing layout.
Adding to GarGraves, Ross or Curtis track is very
easy, since the rail cross section and tie
thickness are virtually identical to that of
Atlas track. Simply butt the rail ends together
and use Atlas rail joiners to connect the two
brands. With GarGraves flex track, the vertical
web under the rail, which is inserted into the
ties, will have to be cut away for a short
distance to allow the rail joiner to slide on.
Transition
rail joiners for connecting to Lionel and K-Line
track will also be available in the near future.
A
Lionel-type remote uncoupling track will be
offered in the 1.75" length. And, for lovers
of remote milk cars, cattle cars, etc. (like me),
Atlas will offer a kit to convert any 10"
straight into a remote-control track section.
Flip over a piece of straight track and
youll notice that holes have already been
provided for this.
When
a company with Atlas experience in model
railroading enters the 3-rail market, its a
sign that our branch of the hobby is strong and
growing. The highly realistic 21st Century Track
System is a perfect complement to the
scale-detailed engines and rolling stock that
havce become the norm, rather than the exception.
Short of switching to 2-rail DC (OK, I admit to
occasional longings), this is as good as track is
going to get for those of us who run 3-rail
trains at least until somebody invents a
virtual third rail.
|